Mansfield Park

July 29, 2007 Categories: Books , Reviews | 10 Comments  

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

Update: Ron mentioned to me that this post contains plot spoilers, and I want to make sure you are forewarned. So there, you’re forewarned. ;)

I could call this the summer of Austen and Harry. What a contrast! And yet both delightful and hard to put down. I enjoyed Mansfield Park, and was glad to find that after reading most of Austen’s works, she can still surprise me.

I thought for sure that when Henry proposed to Fanny, Edmund would realize he was in love with her. Wrong! Edmund was all for the match, and though he understood Fanny’s reluctance to get engaged to a man she didn’t love, he assumes she will change her mind. First surprise.

Second surprise: when it seems that Henry’s character had truly changed, and Fanny seemed to be softening toward him, I thought maybe Henry would have a true transformation of the heart and Fanny would end up in love with him. Wrong again! Henry ran off with Fanny’s married cousin, Maria.

I loved reading about Fanny as a character, but I’m not sure that I would like to know her. She would make anyone’s character look bad by comparison! She has unending patience and devotion to her Aunt Bertram, who basically treats her like she was raised to give her someone to pour tea, partner her at cards, and fix the snarls in her handiwork. Fanny never loses her patience with Mrs. Norris, her other aunt – and I’m sure I would’ve punched her in the nose! Fanny holds her tongue when Edmund is determined to marry Mary Crawford, the most shallow, self-centered woman he could find. And she stays at her biological family’s home for far longer than I could’ve lasted – given her drunken, swearing father and obnoxious younger brothers. I definitely have found the Austen character I am the most unlike!

I gave this book 4 and a half stars, although I have given all of Austen’s other works five. At the end of the book, she stops showing us things and tells us how everything turns out. After Maria’s disappearance with Henry and Julia’s elopement with Mr. Yates, the final chapter is a “this is how things turned out” narrative. I was disappointed – I would have liked to read how Edmund and Fanny’s love story played out, I wanted to read the scene where he realizes his love for her and she confesses that she had loved him all along. Instead, we are told that he realizes his love, they get engaged, his father approves, they get married, and Fanny’s sister Susan takes Fanny’s place as a companion to her Aunt Bertram – but none of these scenes are actually described, none of the dialogue written. It almost feels like Austen thought the book was getting too long and she better wrap things up. It was still a very enjoyable read, though.


  1. Lawanda

    Yeah, that is one reason I am just not fond of Mansfield Park. I always wanna shake Fanny into yelling at someone! (Oh, and run off with Henry myself! *covers mouth with hand* Can you believe me?!?! haha)

    I really like Edmund, but I lose patience with him for being infatuated with a jerk, and not realizing it! :-p

  2. tribeofautodidacts

    I love Jane Austen (and Harry) too. :-)

  3. carrie

    Lawanda – so you like cads, huh? ;)

    Tribe – me, too – thanks for stopping by!

  4. Birdie

    I love Jane Austen. Now I’m wanting to go read something by her again. I really shouldn’t, though. My currently “to be read” stack of books is already out of control!

  5. carrie

    Birdie – I know the feeling!

  6. Lawanda

    Well, not really, but I guess I like the thought of reforming them ;) hehe

  7. carrie

    Lawanda – that kind of thinking can get you in trouble! I know -I used to always be attracted to the “dark and disturbed” type – then I learned my lesson. Kevin is dark, but only mildly disturbed. ;)

  8. Lawanda

    hahaha Well, I married a good guy, so no worries! :)

    I dated a few crazies in my time though :p

  9. Ron

    Spoiler ;) I’ll add it to my reading list.

  10. carrie

    Ron – oops! I added a warning. You’ll like it, I’m sure.